10 Comments
User's avatar
Richard Corin's avatar

"Since government spending isn’t producing or consuming anything, the One Lesson (see below) tells us that there’s no free lunch here."

I hope you are not saying governments don't produce anything. When the government spends, it may not make apples appear by magic, but it does produce MONEY. It also causes a whole chain of real production to take place. As the currency sovereign, the government's financial net worth is effectively infinity - so infinity minus something equals infinity. However the economy it owns and manages does have a limited productive capacity to make apples appear.

If apples can appear from nowhere and we call that "production" then it is even easier for something notional, such as money, to pop into existence.

You do not mention how money gets a value. It is in demand to pay taxes. Taxation makes fiat money valuable.

On judgement day, when nobody needs any money to make an economy work, the government can tax all its money back and pay out all its liabilities. What's the problem?

Economics21st's avatar

Thanks for the comment! I'll try to clarify what I mean.

First, I'd say that I only call economic activity "production" when someone gains a tangible asset on their balance sheet, and nobody else's assets (or liabilities) change. It increases the products available for their consumption. So, for example, harvesting an apple is a form of production. (We can discuss how to think about where the apple comes from originally if you like).

The creation of money is different. Watch carefully any time Steve Keen fills in Godley tables where there's money creation, and you'll see that the recipient gains an asset (RNW↑), but the bank which issues the money gains a liability (RNW↓). So production is net positive for the world's RNW, but creation of money is zero-sum, even though it's effortless.

Here's an illustration of the government buying a photocopier.

https://www.economics21st.com/i/143676573/buying-goods-and-services

Notice how every arrow which points towards someone (RNW↑) also points away from someone else (RNW↓). This diagram doesn't show the production itself, which is where the increase in the world's RNW comes from. But we could show it as being produced by the seller (or by someone else who sold it to them), not by the government. You can argue that the government adds to the demand for it, but that's not the same as producing it, just like you aren't producing apples when you buy them from the supermarket. The producer produces, and you eventually buy the product by swapping something for it.

Before I discuss your phrase "the government's financial net worth is effectively infinity", I need to ask you if you're familiar with the concepts of solvency and liquidity. Does it make sense to you if I say the government has infinite *liquidity*, but like anyone else, its (Raw) Net Worth is just its assets minus its liabilities?

I actually rarely, if ever, discuss the concept of value. I simply look at what each person(/entity) owns, is owed and owes; how those change over time; and what "invariants" exist i.e. what remains true no matter what events occur. Taxation reduces private sector assets and public sector liabilities, and is therefore also zero-sum.

I think it's undeniable that the existence of government-issued money circulating in the economy has a significant role in adjusting people's behaviour. But the RNW model shows up the fundamental constraints and compromises, which simply can't be broken, any more than Newton's laws of motion can be (leaving aside QM and relativity). I wrote about that here:

https://www.economics21st.com/p/newtonian-laws-for-economics

Thanks again for your comment. I'm interested in challenges to my analysis, and I hope we can both benefit from discussing it.

Richard Corin's avatar

On financial assets first. I agree that the grand sum of all financial assets and liabilities is zero, but do not see a problem with one entity maintaining a permanent (or even expanding) negative balance in order to facilitate the illusion of savings. Anytime a monetary sovereign really wants to kill the economy, it has the power to reduce its negative balance to zero, by taxing away the entire amount of fiat money that it spent into the economy and use it to pay out bonds and bank reserves - just before taxing back that cash. Because it has the power to do this, it remains "solvent". If this ever did hypothetically occur, only credit money would remain in circulation and the economy would soon collapse as the businesses and people of that nation quickly became insolvent.

Now, when you talk about (Raw) Net Worth, you are suddenly including all other kinds of assets, some of which do indeed have infinite value. Since you wish to avoid assigning monetary values to these, then, from my perspective, your notion of Raw Net Worth must be a multidimensional sum of non-interchangeable (orthogonal) entities. Because you (probably wisely) try not to equate money with these other assets, then it is not actually possible to sell things for money, so privatisation is not possible - and a definition of "solvency" which includes real assets is somewhat problematic.

An economics without a theory of value is not economics at all - at best, it is merely accounting. What is the value of natural resources? What is the value of the air you breath if you allow anyone to "own" it (to restrict your access to it)?

"Belongs to nobody" reminds me of "terra-nullius". Apologies for getting confusing at the end, but I am being called away. Cheers.

Economics21st's avatar

Thanks for the reply. There's quite a lot to respond to there, so I'll just try to address the main points.

1. It's certainly possible for a government to run a permanent debt, which it has no intention of ever settling. But it's often useful to consider separately the real economy of goods and services, and the financial economy of debts. The real economy is what's truly important. The financial economy is there as a record of promises to resolve imbalances in (ultimately) the real economy in the future - it saves having to use a commodity as money. I talk about debts as temporary compensation for real economy imbalances in this article from the Macroeconomics series:

https://www.economics21st.com/p/the-financial-economy-1

If the imbalance in the financial economy is permanent, then those who lost out in the real economy imbalance are *never* compensated.

2. Yes, with RNW, I'm certainly talking about a vector with an enormous (but still finite) number of dimensions for the different types of thing. Given how I think about value (how much of something else a person would be prepared to trade for it), I'm not sure what you mean by some things having infinite value, since nobody has an infinite amount of anything to trade. What do you mean when you talk of infinite value?

Just because I don't have an objective theory of value doesn't mean that people can't buy things. It's just that I don't claim to predict when they will. If Bob decides to buy 10 apples from Alice for $2, she transfers 10 apples to him (purple arrow), and he transfers $2 to her (green arrow). Each of those transfers is a zero-sum action. If Alice insists on $3, and Bob agrees, then 10 apples are swapped for $3, again in two zero-sum actions.

3. I don't see the RNW model as being all there is to economics. But I do think it makes a powerful foundation, which explains a lot by itself, and other ideas can be built on top of it. What it offers are (a) its axioms are so self-evident that they should be uncontroversial, i.e. there are entities which can own, be owed and owe things, (b) it is linear: there's no fallacy of composition, (c) it's easy to represent in arrow diagrams, (d) it's quite intuitive, and (e) it's universal: it doesn't assume a particular type of economy. I really think that there's a very close analogy between this and Newton's laws of motion.

Richard Corin's avatar

1. I quite like your point one. But there is an unnecessary twist or distorted value judgement colouring the proposition at the end. I cannot go along with this bit:- "If the imbalance in the financial economy is permanent, then those who lost out in the real economy imbalance are *never* compensated."

The imbalance is a dynamic one. Nobody loses out because everybody can cash in their assets at the appointed time or before. However, it just so happens that their assets, their savings, (aka government debt) are very likely to be replaced almost immediately by somebody else's voluntary savings - thereby maintaining a fluctuating dynamic balance of government debt.

Here's another analogy. Do bank depositors "lose out" from the permanent (dynamic) pool of bank debt? When you decide not to spend all your money today, and put (or leave) your money in your bank account, are you really "losing out"? Nobody loses out from these permanent voluntary dynamic balances - until the music stops with the collapse of civilisation. Then everyone loses out.

What you call government DEBT (because it IS a liability) is not at all like personal debt. The government is satisfying the savings desires of the non-bank private sector. It is providing a service at extremely minimum risk to investors. It is not impoverishing the country or heading towards insolvency.

2. Infinite value. Think about the replacement value of the irreplaceable. Does life on Earth have a value beyond money?

If you want to get mathematically pedantic, you might prefer "undefined", but that is "infinity's" twin sister. (And they are both the children of zero.)

"...nobody has an infinite amount of anything to trade." It is interesting that you limit value to what somebody can afford to pay, rather than consider what cannot be afforded. Most humans are capable of valuing something more highly than their own lives. So here I must open the Pandora's Box of subjectivity. If someone is willing to give everything they have, then that, too has infinite value - for some at least.

In your foundational model, you are sticking with "exchange values" as determined by subjective individuals at a moment in time. In the real world, of course, these momentarily factual exchange values change dynamically, so the subjective "zero sum" exchange applies only for a moment, for a specific transaction. Apples are growing and rotting all the time - and they are seasonal. Value is not conserved, and that fact really messes up your ledgers because they change even when no transactions occur.

Now all this is getting terribly close to value theory, so I will mention some thoughts about that. Subjectively, there are needs and wants and an ability to pay. There is a time varying hierarchy of preferences which can be swamped by the overriding need for the necessities of life. Objectively, there are statistical phenomena such as "scarcity" and "market prices".

How much are you willing to pay Elon for breathable air when you work for him on Mars? I am very interested in the power relationships which enable extortionate market pricing through to economic slavery. And I tend to attribute "infinite" value to the irreplaceable - especially the free gifts of nature. There is a practical reason for this. In my view, these things should not become part of financial calculations - and nothing stuffs up a calculation like an infinity.

I'm not saying these "resources" cannot be used, but they do need to be maintained. I'm saying that the realm of money and economic calculation must remain subservient to more fundamental values.

By way of analogy, "Thou Shalt Not Kill" does not discuss the economics nor the exchange value of a person's life, but we don't complain about the consequence that it increases the market price of a "hit"- because such laws serve a higher value. I do hope you are OK with that.

BTW. One thing I would require of your foundational model, before I took it seriously - more than a primitive model - is a ledger for "the world" - the source of all production. Since you seem to assume there is a pre-existing private ownership of the free gifts of Nature, then I suppose only "The Commons" remains as a label for the non-private, or collective, universe. Yes, of course it is difficult.

Richard Corin's avatar

On a second reading, I now think we do have some things in common. I do not like the government paying interest on reserves or on bonds. This is because it is a subsidy for the wealthy. The problem discussed above is less concerned about the monetary sovereign's ability to create money and has much more to do with the issuing of debt - converting reserves into bonds - accepting liability for private sector savings - and worse, paying the private sector interest on the money which the government created.

Issuing bonds is something which governments do "voluntarily", by which I mean I am not at all convinced that "issuing government debt" or "accepting deposits", is a necessary function of a monetary sovereign unless the banking system is entirely public. A continuously accumulating liability that enriches the private sector according to how much money the have already, means that taxation has to be higher in order to control inflation.

In favour of issuing bonds:-

providing the safest investment vehicle for savings has a stabilising effect on the financial sector. Not only does it provide control of interest rates, but it also reduces the amount of savings that would otherwise be forced into asset bubble speculation. By encouraging long term savings, cash is temporarily removed from circulation, so part of today's inflation problems can be shifted to the future. I am sure there are more effective ways to adjust the money supply, but they tend not to make people feel good about voluntarily limiting their consumption spending. I am not so confident about the benefits of time shifting spending because it is possible that bonds are readily convertible into cash at any time. I'm no expert here.